Disagreeing with definitions used in a claim isn't orthogonal to disagreeing with the claim - Socratrees

Disagreeing with definitions used in a claim isn't orthogonal to disagreeing with the claim

6

posted Mar 21, 2022

Disagreeing with a claim requires agreeing with the definitions used therein

1

0

2

0
If you disagree on using a term to express something, you will be hesitant to opine on a claim using it as such

2

1

1

1
If you disagree on using a term to express something, you will be hesitant to publicly opine on a claim using it as such

2

2

1

3

It is possible to disagree with the definitions used in a claim, but agree with the claim given these definitions

2

1

2

0
It is possible to agree with the definitions used in a claim, but disagree with the claim given these definitions

2

0

2

0
Disagreeing on the definitions used in a claim is about disagreeing on how to express the claim

1

0

2

1